SupplementScore explained: how we rate supplements from A+ to E
The SupplementScore is our quality rating for supplements: one letter from A+ to E per product, based on what the label promises and what can be checked. It looks at the active ingredient and its form, the dose you actually get per day and unnecessary additives, plus a lab report in some categories. Brands can’t buy a letter, and commission doesn’t change it.
In short
- 818 listings on Mr Suppy carry a letter (11 November 2026), across ten categories. Each flavour and size is a separate listing.
- 17% score A+, 52% A, 28% B and 2% C. One product scores D, none scores E.
- The criteria per category were reviewed by endocrinologist Dr Diederik Smit and his colleagues at Android Health Clinic.
- Every rating is in a public data file that you can check and reuse.
What does each letter mean?
An A means a product meets the standard for its category: an effective ingredient in a sensible form, at a dose in line with the evidence, without padding. An A+ is the top score in a category’s model, and what it takes differs: for whey 9 or 10 of 10 points, for creatine and omega-3 also a lab report. Some categories, such as protein bars and electrolytes, have no A+. B, C and D mean a product falls short on one or more points, for example a dose below the threshold. E is the lowest letter; no product on Mr Suppy has one at the moment.
A letter says something about the product, not about you. Whether you need creatine, magnesium or a vitamin D supplement depends on your goal and your diet. For medical questions, speak to your GP.
What do we check on the label?
Each category has its own model, because a good protein powder and a good electrolyte drink have little in common. Most come down to three questions:
- Is the active ingredient effective, and in a form that works?
- How much do you get per day, at the lowest daily serving the brand recommends?
- Are there unnecessary additives, and is the label honest?
Some examples from the current models. Creatine needs at least 3 g of creatine monohydrate a day for an A, and an independent lab report of the product as sold for an A+. Whey protein is scored on protein per serving, leucine, protein per 100 g and the amino acid profile, flavour by flavour, because those numbers differ between flavours of the same powder. An electrolyte drink scores an A with 400 to 1,200 mg of sodium per litre as prepared.
Who reviews the criteria?
The criteria for each category were reviewed by Dr Diederik Smit, an endocrinologist at Android Health Clinic (AHC), and his colleagues there. They check whether the thresholds hold and whether evidence is strong enough to count. On Mr Suppy, 477 of the 818 listings belong to products AHC reviewed itself. The other 341 were worked out by us, by applying their published criteria to the label. The open data says which of the two applies to each listing.
When AHC changes a rule, the model gets a new version number and date. The open data shows which version each letter uses.
What the numbers show (11 November 2026)
| Category | Listings | A+ | A | B | C or lower |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whey protein | 574 | 127 | 285 | 149 | 13 |
| Creatine | 112 | 0 | 110 | 2 | 0 |
| Protein bars | 70 | 0 | 0 | 70 | 0 |
| Protein breakfast | 16 | 0 | 16 | 0 | 0 |
| Pre-workout | 15 | 9 | 3 | 3 | 0 |
| Electrolytes | 10 | 0 | 10 | 0 | 0 |
| Magnesium | 7 | 0 | 0 | 4 | 3 |
| Omega-3 | 6 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 4 |
| Sports drinks | 5 | 5 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Vitamin D | 3 | 0 | 2 | 1 | 0 |
Creatine shows how simple a good product can be: 110 of the 112 listings score an A, because nearly all of them give you 3 g of monohydrate a day. None scores an A+ yet, because none of them has a public lab report of the product as sold. Whey has the widest spread, from 127 listings with an A+ to 13 with a C or lower. Compare products on our best whey protein and best creatine pages.
Does commission change the letter?
No. The letter comes from the label and the model, and partner status plays no part in the calculation. We may earn commission when you buy through our links. The public data shows that per product. In other countries the same model also rates brands we don’t work with, and they get the same letter for the same label.
Brands can’t pay for a letter. If you think a letter is wrong, the data gives you the model version and, for points models, the total score, so you can check our working. For a wider view of what’s worth taking, read which supplements actually work.
Author and sources
Written by the Mr Suppy editorial team. Criteria medically reviewed by Dr Diederik Smit, endocrinologist, Android Health Clinic. Figures checked on 11 November 2026.
- SupplementScore open data for Mr Suppy: mrsuppy.com/supplementscore.json (letters, model versions, reviewer and partner status per product).
- SupplementScore methodology and quality mark: supplementscore.eu (in Dutch).
- Model version and review date per category: in the same data file.
Frequently asked questions
Is the SupplementScore a lab test?
Not on its own. The letter is based on the label and the category model. Lab evidence counts in some models: for creatine and omega-3, an A+ needs a lab report.
Can I use the ratings?
Yes. The ratings are free to use under a CC BY 4.0 licence, on one condition: cite SupplementScore as the source.
How often do the letters change?
A letter can change, for example when the label changes or AHC updates a model. The data file is rebuilt every day and shows the date it was generated.