Independent compared, no shop of our ownEvery day new deals and codesSupplementScore on every productTraining, food and supplements in one app. Discover Kroton
Knowledge base
Supplements

Which supplements actually work? A doctor’s verdict

Updated on 22 October 2026

For most people, two supplements are worth taking: vitamin D and omega-3. That is the verdict of Diederik Smit, an internist and endocrinologist who assessed 54 products on their labels for our SupplementScore. If you lift weights, add creatine, and take whey only when food doesn’t cover your protein. “A lot of supplements do absolutely nothing,” he says.

In short

  • Most people: vitamin D in autumn and winter, and omega-3 with at least 1,000 mg of EPA and DHA a day.
  • If you train: 3 g of creatine monohydrate a day, plus whey if you fall short of 1.6–2 g of protein per kilo.
  • Only with a clear goal: magnesium, at 200–400 mg of elemental magnesium.

Vitamin D and omega-3: useful for most people

Between October and early March the UK sun is too weak for your skin to make enough vitamin D, so the NHS says everyone should consider a daily 10 microgram supplement in autumn and winter. Vitamin D contributes to the maintenance of normal bones and to the normal function of the immune system. You rarely notice a shortfall unless you have a blood test, says Smit. Our SupplementScore uses 2,000 IU (50 micrograms) a day, well under the NHS maximum of 100 micrograms. Added K2 makes no difference, as vitamin D3 and K2 explains.

With omega-3, what counts is EPA and DHA, the fatty acids in oily fish such as salmon and mackerel. Smit’s rule is oily fish twice a week, or a supplement if you don’t manage that. Read the EPA and DHA on the ingredients list, not the grams of fish oil on the front, and aim for at least 1,000 mg a day. Very high intakes are linked to atrial fibrillation, a heart rhythm disorder. More in our article on omega-3.

Creatine and whey: useful if you train

Creatine increases physical performance in successive bursts of short-term, high intensity exercise, with a daily intake of 3 g. “It’s the best-researched supplement we have,” says Smit. Take 3 g of creatine monohydrate every day, roughly 1 g per 20 kg of body weight, with no loading phase and at any time of day. Almost all monohydrate products scored the same, so don’t be led up the garden path by special forms or colours. The best-scoring ones are on our best creatine page.

Protein contributes to a growth in muscle mass, but you only need whey if meat, fish, eggs and dairy don’t get you to 1.6–2 g of protein per kilo of body weight a day. Look for at least 20 g of protein per scoop; whether it is concentrate, isolate or a blend matters little. Our guide to which protein powder to buy helps you choose.

Magnesium and pre-workout: only with a goal

“Magnesium for everyone because it’s good for you? I think that’s real nonsense,” says Smit. Magnesium contributes to normal muscle function, but without a shortfall or a clear goal it isn’t a useful supplement. There is no authorised claim for magnesium and sleep, and for ordinary leg cramps a Cochrane review (Garrison and colleagues, 2020) found it probably makes no meaningful difference. If you take it, aim for 200–400 mg of elemental magnesium; the NHS says 400 mg or less a day from supplements is unlikely to cause any harm.

Pre-workout is the hardest category to score, because it is a blend. According to Smit, caffeine and beta-alanine have the best data. Caffeine has no approved health claims, and EFSA (2015) puts the safe limit for a healthy adult at 200 mg in one go and 400 mg a day.

What is marketing?

Much of what makes a tub look premium doesn’t count in the SupplementScore. Take K2 added to vitamin D: the mechanism is real, but clinical studies haven’t shown stronger bones. “Vitamin K doesn’t make your vitamin D any better,” says Smit. Omega-3, -6 and -9 blends are another: you get omega-6 and omega-9 easily from food, so it’s the omega-3 that counts.

Creatine in colours, flavours or forms other than monohydrate has no proven advantage. According to Smit, HCL and ethyl ester are even less suitable, because part of them breaks down before it reaches your body. Whey that “mixes better” or has a pricier brand name usually has the same label as a cheaper one. And a magnesium complex with four compounds is a red flag when the tub gives you only 50 to 100 mg of magnesium per dose.

What can a blood test tell you?

Vitamin D is easy to measure. Smit’s advice is to start with a maintenance dose, have a blood test after three to six months, ideally at the end of winter, and to consider a level above 75 nmol/l good. The omega-3 index can be measured too, but it isn’t a routine GP test; a few private labs offer it.

“Please don’t get your magnesium tested,” says Smit, because the level in your blood says very little about your stores and can reassure you wrongly. For creatine and protein a blood test is no use either: you judge them by your training and your diet.

Frequently asked questions

Which supplements should I take for the gym?

Creatine monohydrate first, 3 g a day, or up to 5 g if you are very heavy and muscular. Then whey, but only if your diet doesn’t cover your protein. Pre-workout and clear whey are about taste and convenience, not need.

Is the SupplementScore independent?

Smit personally assessed some of the products on their labels, unpaid, and has no ties to supplement brands; he didn’t even know most of them. Brands never pay for a rating.

Can supplements replace a good diet?

No. If you already eat enough protein, a shake adds little. Get your food, sleep and training right first; a supplement is the last piece.

Read more

All articles