Vitamin D3 and K2: do you need K2 with your vitamin D?
No, you don’t need K2 with your vitamin D. The biology behind the combination is real, but clinical studies have not shown that adding K2 leads to stronger bones, fewer fractures or less calcium in your arteries, says Diederik Smit, an internist and endocrinologist who personally assessed some of the vitamin D products in our SupplementScore. What does count is the vitamin D itself: the NHS advises everyone to consider 10 micrograms a day in autumn and winter.
In short
- K2 with vitamin D: no proven extra benefit, so don’t pay more for it.
- NHS: consider 10 micrograms (400 IU) of vitamin D a day from October to early March; some people need it all year.
- Maximum for adults: 100 micrograms (4,000 IU) a day, according to the NHS.
- Taking warfarin? The NHS says not to take vitamin K supplements.
Why vitamin D matters in the UK
Your skin makes vitamin D in sunlight. According to the NHS, most people can make all they need from about late March or early April to the end of September. Between October and early March the sun in the UK is too weak, which is why everyone should consider a daily 10 microgram supplement in autumn and winter. People who are rarely outdoors, live in a care home or cover most of their skin outside should take 10 micrograms all year, and people with dark skin may need to as well.
Vitamin D contributes to the maintenance of normal bones, to the maintenance of normal muscle function and to the normal function of the immune system. Food gives you some: oily fish, red meat, egg yolks and fortified spreads and breakfast cereals. Cow’s milk in the UK is generally not fortified. You rarely feel a shortfall; tiredness and low mood often have other causes, as our article on always feeling tired explains.
How much vitamin D a day?
The NHS baseline is 10 micrograms a day. Smit adds that 400 to 800 IU lifts people out of a severe deficiency, but that a good blood level often takes more, which is why our SupplementScore uses 2,000 IU a day as a maintenance dose. That stays well below the NHS maximum.
| Daily dose | What it means |
|---|---|
| 400 IU (10 micrograms) | NHS advice for autumn and winter |
| 1,000 IU (25 micrograms) | better, but many people still have a low level, says Smit |
| 2,000 IU (50 micrograms) | maintenance dose in our SupplementScore |
| 4,000 IU (100 micrograms) | NHS maximum for adults; don’t go higher |
Smit’s advice is to start with a maintenance dose and have a blood test after three to six months, ideally at the end of winter; he considers a level above 75 nmol/l good. Take your tablet with your main meal, so there is fat to help absorption. An oil capsule doesn’t make the product better.
What does vitamin K2 do?
Vitamin K is a cofactor for two proteins. Osteocalcin lets bone cells lay down bone mineral, and matrix GLA protein is involved in keeping calcium out of the walls of your blood vessels. Without vitamin K those proteins don’t work properly. The authorised claims are that vitamin K contributes to normal blood clotting and to the maintenance of normal bones.
The NHS says adults need about 1 microgram of vitamin K a day for each kilo of body weight, and that green leafy vegetables such as broccoli and spinach, vegetable oils and cereal grains provide it. Most people get enough from a varied diet. Taking 1 mg or less a day from supplements is unlikely to cause any harm, according to the NHS.
Why K2 with vitamin D is mainly marketing
Manufacturers say that K2 “sends calcium to the right place”. That describes the mechanism, but in Smit’s words: “Clinical research still hasn’t convincingly shown that adding vitamin K leads to better bone mineral density, let alone fewer fractures or less calcification of the blood vessels in the long run.” When you have a shortage of vitamin K those processes suffer; above an adequate level, extra K2 probably adds nothing.
There is another catch. The small Japanese studies that showed a slight benefit for the heart and blood vessels used high doses of the MK-4 form, while most supplements contain MK-7 at a much lower dose. In our SupplementScore, K2 is therefore neither a plus nor a minus. Choose your vitamin D on its dose and price in our comparison, not on whether K2 is added.
Warfarin and other precautions
Vitamin K affects how warfarin works. The NHS is clear: do not take vitamin K supplements while you are taking warfarin, and talk to your anticoagulant clinic about foods high in vitamin K. If you take any other blood-thinning medicine, check with your GP or pharmacist before you buy a product with K2.
For vitamin D, stay within the NHS maximum of 100 micrograms (4,000 IU) a day for adults, as more could be harmful. Children aged 1 to 10 should not have more than 50 micrograms a day. If your GP finds a deficiency, they will set the dose for you.
Frequently asked questions
Is vitamin D with K2 better than vitamin D alone?
Not according to the clinical data. The mechanism is sound, but studies don’t show better bone density, fewer fractures or less calcification from adding K2. Choose on the vitamin D dose.
Should I take vitamin D in summer?
Most people make enough from sunlight between late March and the end of September, so the NHS calls a supplement optional then. If you are rarely outdoors or cover your skin, take it all year.
Should I take fish oil with vitamin D?
It isn’t needed for absorption, but Smit counts vitamin D and omega-3 as the two supplements useful for most people. Why omega-3 matters is in our article on omega-3.