Which protein powder should you buy? The right choice by goal
For most people who train, a whey concentrate from a big brand is the right buy, and Myprotein Impact Whey is the obvious place to start: 21 g of protein per 25 g scoop (82%) according to Myprotein, a full amino acid profile on the label and, with a discount code, almost always one of the lowest prices per kilo. If you are cutting or lactose upsets your stomach, choose an isolate such as Myprotein Impact Whey Isolate, which is around 90% protein.
This guide shows how to judge a powder from its label and which type suits which goal, based on labels and our price data rather than sponsored reviews.
In short
- All-rounder: Myprotein Impact Whey, 82% protein, usually the lowest price per kilo of the big brands.
- Cutting or lactose: an isolate with at least 88% protein, for example Myprotein Impact Whey Isolate.
- Check four things: protein per serving, price per kilo after discount, a short ingredient list and under 2 g of sugar per serving.
- Paying more rarely buys you more muscle: above those thresholds you mostly pay for the brand.
How do you judge a protein powder?
You can check four points yourself on any product page, so you don’t have to take our word for it.
- Protein per serving. Divide the grams of protein by the scoop size. For a concentrate, 75% or more is good; for an isolate, 88% or more.
- Price per kilo after discount. Not the price of the bag, but what a kilo costs once the current code has been applied.
- A short ingredient list. The fewer additions, the better. A full amino acid profile printed on the label is a plus.
- Sugar. Under 2 g per serving.
Also stick to whey from large, established brands such as Myprotein, Optimum Nutrition, Applied Nutrition and Bulk: they sell in large volumes, so stock turns over quickly.
Best all-rounder: Myprotein Impact Whey
Myprotein Impact Whey has been one of Europe’s best-selling protein powders for years, and the label explains why: 82% protein according to Myprotein, a full amino acid profile and, after a discount, a price per kilo that few big brands beat. It also comes in a long list of flavours. For building muscle, a concentrate like this is all you need. Protein contributes to a growth in muscle mass, and whether that protein comes from a concentrate or an isolate makes no difference to it.
Prefer another big name? Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey is a blend of concentrate and isolate and a long-standing classic, although it usually costs more per serving. Applied Nutrition and Bulk, both British brands, are worth comparing on price per kilo as well. The current Myprotein code is on our Myprotein page.
Best isolate: for cutting and a sensitive stomach
In an isolate, most of the fat and lactose has been filtered out, leaving almost pure protein. That makes it the better choice when you are cutting and every calorie counts, or when lactose leaves you bloated. Myprotein Impact Whey Isolate gives 23 g of protein per 25 g scoop in the unflavoured version (92%) and 21 to 22 g in the flavoured ones. Optimum Nutrition and Applied Nutrition make isolates too.
An isolate usually costs more per kilo than a concentrate, although offers sometimes turn that around. So ask yourself whether you need it. If lactose doesn’t bother you and you are not cutting, you pay extra for a difference you won’t notice in the gym. Which isolate is cheapest changes with the offers; today’s prices are on our cheapest whey isolate page.
Best on a budget: the cheapest of the big brands
The cheapest whey from a big brand changes almost every week, because the discounts change. That is why the ranking lives in our comparison rather than in this article: our cheapest whey protein page sorts today’s prices per kilo with the discount already included.
Two rules help when you want to save. Always work it out per kilo, not per bag, because the larger bag is almost always cheaper per kilo. And only buy the big bag once you know you like the flavour. A 5 kg bag in a flavour you can’t stand costs you more than any discount saves.
Concentrate, blend or isolate?
A concentrate is the cheapest option and is fine for most people: roughly 70 to 82% protein, plus a little fat and lactose. A blend of concentrate and isolate sits in between on price and digestibility. An isolate, at 88% protein or more, is almost pure protein and the easiest to digest, but usually costs more per kilo.
Looking for something other than a classic milkshake-style whey? Clear whey is a light, fruity drink made from isolate, popular in summer and when you are cutting; our guide to the best clear whey compares the options. Vegan protein made from pea and rice is the alternative if you avoid dairy altogether.
Frequently asked questions
Which protein powder is best for beginners?
A whey concentrate from a big brand, such as Myprotein Impact Whey. It is affordable, mixes easily and gives you around 20 g of protein per scoop. Start with a small bag so you can try the flavour before you commit.
Is expensive protein powder better?
Not automatically. The price depends on the brand, the bag size and the discount, not on how well the protein works. Compare protein per serving and price per kilo: an expensive concentrate with 75% protein is not a better product than a cheaper one with 82%.
Do I need protein powder at all?
No, not if you reach your daily target with foods such as Greek yoghurt, eggs, meat, fish and beans. Protein powder is a convenient food, not a meal replacement. It earns its place when you regularly fall 20 to 30 g short of your daily goal.