Independent compared, no shop of our ownEvery day new deals and codesSupplementScore on every productTraining, food and supplements in one app. Discover Kroton
Knowledge base
Supplements

Protein powder for weight loss: clear whey, isolate or casein?

Updated on 21 October 2026

The best protein powder for losing weight is a clear whey or a whey isolate: plenty of protein for few calories, with almost no fat or sugar. Clear whey drinks like a fruity squash; an isolate gives you a classic shake. The powder doesn’t make you lose weight on its own, though. You lose weight by eating fewer calories than you burn, and a shake only helps if it replaces something rather than coming on top.

In short

  • An isolate has around 100 kcal per scoop; a concentrate is often 20 to 30 kcal more because of fat and lactose.
  • Look for 88% protein or more in an isolate and under 2 g of sugar per serving.
  • During a cut, many people who train aim for 1.6 to 2.2 g of protein per kilo of body weight a day.
  • One or two shakes a day is plenty; the rest of your protein comes from food.

Why protein matters when you're losing weight

When you eat less, you want to lose fat rather than muscle. Protein contributes to the maintenance of muscle mass, which is exactly what you want to protect in a calorie deficit, especially if you keep lifting weights. That is why many people who train push their protein up during a cut, to somewhere between 1.6 and 2.2 g per kilo of body weight a day.

Reaching that from food alone can be hard when your calories are low. A shake is no miracle, but it is the easiest way to add 20 to 30 g of protein without adding many calories. How to set up a cut properly, with the deficit, the macros and the training, is covered in our guide to losing fat without losing muscle.

What should you check on the label?

Three numbers tell you most of what you need to know, and they are all on the label:

  • Calories per serving. An isolate sits around 100 kcal per scoop. A concentrate is often 20 to 30 kcal higher because it contains more fat and lactose.
  • Protein per serving. Divide the grams of protein by the weight of the scoop. For an isolate you want 88% or more.
  • Sugar. Under 2 g per serving. Clear whey and isolates manage that easily.

Calories from your shake count like any other calories. If you mix your powder with whole milk or blend it with banana and peanut butter, that shake can easily reach several hundred kcal. With water, an isolate stays light.

Clear whey, isolate or casein?

Clear whey Whey isolate
Drinks like squash or juice a milkshake
Mix with water water or milk
Protein per serving 20 to 27 g 21 to 30 g
Fat and sugar almost none very little

Clear whey is the lightest option: refreshing, with hardly any fat, and pleasant after a hard session or in summer. The protein percentage differs quite a lot between brands, so compare it per serving. An isolate is the better cutting choice if you prefer a creamy shake: almost pure protein, with little fat and lactose. Casein is a third option. It digests slowly, which is why some people use it as an evening shake.

Which products to compare

For clear whey, our comparison includes Myprotein Clear Whey Protein Isolate, Applied Nutrition Clear Whey Protein Isolate and Optimum Nutrition Clear Protein; the cheapest clear whey page sorts them by today’s price per serving. For a classic isolate there are Myprotein Impact Whey Isolate (92% protein unflavoured, 21 to 22 g per 25 g scoop in the flavours), Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate and Applied Nutrition BodyFuel Whey Protein Isolate, all on our cheapest whey isolate page.

Some products are sold as diet whey and may contain added ingredients. Judge them on protein per serving, calories and price like any other powder. Not sure which type suits you? Our guide to which protein powder to buy sorts it by goal.

How to use shakes when you're cutting

  • Fewer calories: you lose weight by eating less than you burn, not because of the powder.
  • Instead of, not on top of: let a shake replace a snack or part of a meal.
  • Not every meal: a shake lacks the fibre, vitamins and healthy fats of real food. Replacing a meal now and then is fine; as a fixed habit it isn’t.
  • One or two a day: that is enough for most people. Get the rest of your protein from foods such as chicken, fish, eggs, Greek yoghurt, beans and lentils.

Shakes don’t burn belly fat or any other specific fat. Fat loss happens across your whole body and depends on your overall calorie balance, your food and how much you move.

Frequently asked questions

Can you lose weight with protein shakes?

Yes, as long as you are in a calorie deficit. A shake makes it easier to get enough protein while eating less, and protein contributes to the maintenance of muscle mass. Drunk on top of your normal food, a shake just adds calories.

Is clear whey better than normal whey for weight loss?

Not better, just lighter: it drinks like squash and contains almost no fat. Check the protein per serving, because it varies a lot between brands.

Are protein shakes suitable for women who want to lose weight?

Yes, they are just as suitable for women as for men. They help you reach your protein target while you eat less, which matters if you want to keep the muscle you have.

Read more

All articles